Guides

Why Well-Designed Research Papers Get Delayed Before Peer Review

Why Well-Designed Research Papers Get Delayed Before Peer Review

Think about this situation. You have completed your research; data validated, results are novel, and you think that publication of the paper will be a simple and straightforward task. However, it doesn't turn out to be that easy. Firstly, the writing of the manuscript doesn't seem to be straightforward. Secondly, the editors and reviewers are either rejecting the manuscript or inviting multiple revisions. All these contribute to delays in the publication of your paper. Sounds familiar?

Read on to understand the common issues that cause peer review delays and how to manage those factors so that you can smoothly sail through the research publication process!

Key reasons for manuscript submission delays

Most of the manuscript submission delays are triggered by the very first step in manuscript submission – manuscript preparation!

Editors and reviewers do not assess the manuscripts solely based on scientific merit. They also consider the following factors:

  1. Language clarity
  2. Article structure
  3. Flawed abstract
  4. Adherence to journal standards

Language Clarity

Writing scientific content with clarity is a niche skill. But, it's not rocket science. Most of the newbie authors assume that incorrect grammar is the only issue. That's not the sole hurdle. In scientific communication, logic and clarity are key requirements.

Editors and reviewers report the following as the most common academic writing issues:

  1. Long and complex sentences that obscure the meaning
  2. Inconsistent terminology across sections
  3. Ambiguous description of methods and results
  4. Illogical flow of thought while discussing the results

Reviewers try to evaluate the research that you present. The academic writing mistakes mentioned above will hamper their comprehension of your manuscript. In addition, confusing and ambiguous content will tire the reviewers quickly, so that they usually end up rejecting the manuscript or send it back for revision with lots of queries. This will result in heavy peer review delays.

Article Structure

A well-structured manuscript is a delight for a reviewer to read and review. Whereas a poorly structured one unnecessarily increases the cognitive load and reviewer fatigue.

IMRAD structure is the commonly accepted scientific manuscript framework. This framework helps you to structure your manuscript in the most logical and meaningful way so that your argument is presented neatly.

Even when this framework is followed, other type of structural issues can still sneak in. Some of these are as follows:

  1. Objectives and conclusions are not aligned
  2. Insufficient or incomplete description of methodologies
  3. Repeating the results verbatim in the discussion section
  4. Too much background information in the introduction
  5. Uncited figures and tables

When the discussion section does not expand on your results, the reviewers might not fully comprehend the significance of the results. Also, your conclusions must strictly be in synch with your results.

These issues can lead the reviewers to completely misunderstand the context and significance of your results and, thus, cause peer review delays.

Adherence to Journal Style and Standards

This parameter is checked right at the beginning of submission by the editorial office even before sending the manuscript for peer review. This is a common factor that leads to desk rejection or delayed peer review. This often stems from authors preparing the manuscript in their own style rather than paying attention to the format specified by the journal.

The author guidelines usually published on the journal's website lists out the specifications for various components of the manuscript. For example, common specifications include length of the article, word count, sections required, requirement of structured abstract and graphical abstract, resolution specs for images, various ethical declarations etc.

However, many authors do not pay attention to these instructions and end up submitting manuscripts that do not adhere to journal guidelines. This will cause outright rejection (also called desk rejection) in most cases.

Flawed Abstract

The abstract is often the first section editors read before deciding whether to proceed with your manuscript. Many editors read only the abstract, when the journal attracts a huge volume of manuscripts. This clearly indicates that a poorly written abstract can negatively impact the chances of acceptance of the paper.

Common abstract-related issues include:

  1. Overly generic problem statements
  2. Vague description of the methodology
  3. Overstated or illogical conclusions

Editors use the abstract to assess journal fit, novelty, and relevance. A weak abstract can result in:

  1. Immediate return without review
  2. Requests for revision before peer review
  3. Misalignment with assigned reviewers

A strong abstract is concise, specific, and faithful to the manuscript. It reduces early-stage friction and ensures the paper enters peer review without unnecessary delays.

Preparing a Submission-Ready Manuscript Efficiently

A smooth, error-free manuscript submission may sound like an impossible task to many. But, in reality it is not so. It can be achieved by any researcher/author with careful planning and systematic preparation.

Effective strategies to achieve this include:

  1. Ensuring the manuscript strictly aligns with the journal specifications
  2. Conducting a pre-submission language and clarity review
  3. Validating consistency across figures, tables, and text
  4. Using a comprehensive journal submission checklist
  5. Ensuring the abstract accurately reflects the study's contribution

Good news is efficient tools are available for authors to ensure that manuscripts are properly formatted, written with logic and clarity, and structurally sound, so that the manuscript moves through the editorial desk and peer-review process without any unnecessary delays.

PaperPerfect is such a tool that checks the manuscript before submission to a journal against the prescribed style of the journal and the important parameters described above. It provides a comprehensive report of all these parameters and helps the authors to ensure strict adherence to the journal guidelines and research publication best practices.