As a researcher/PhD student, you do understand the importance of getting your research published in reputed peer-reviewed journals. While it increases your credibility and academic recognition, the major significance of publishing is that it announces your research to the academic community and initiates intellectual discussions to further the understanding of the subject.
Given the importance of publishing in peer-reviewed journals, it is not an easy task too! You must have observed many times manuscripts getting rejected by journals even when the science is strong. What went wrong here? What exactly are the journals looking for?
Well, the answer is manuscript structure.
A poorly organized manuscript makes it harder for the reviewers to read and understand it. For this reason, many papers, even when the research is strong, get rejected by journals. In this blog, we focus on the globally accepted scientific writing framework, the IMRaD structure, for writing academic research papers.
- To organize a manuscript into logical sections
- To achieve natural and logical flow of thought
- To help reviewers and readers easily grasp the information
What Is IMRaD and Why It Matters
IMRaD stands for Introduction, Methods, Results and Discussion. All academic journals prefer this standardized structure as it helps organize content logically.
A manuscript logically structured using the IMRaD framework reduces the chances of misinterpretation and allows reviewers and readers to focus on science rather than grappling with the presentation.
Common Structure Mistakes Researchers Make
Scientific acumen, lateral thinking, problem solving are the essential strengths of a researcher. However, scientific writing requires an entirely different skillset. Presenting your research findings cohesively using lucid and clear language is a niche skill. Not all researchers might possess this skill. Hence, while writing their research manuscript for submission to academic journals, many researchers do not use proper research paper format and thus end up with their papers getting rejected. Unorganized papers usually have the following issues:
- Incoherent logical flow
- Mixing results with discussion
- Background overload in introduction
- Weak or unclear conclusion
How Poor Structure Impacts Reviewer Decisions
The major problem with poorly structured manuscripts is the incoherent presentation of scientific argument. This unnecessarily increases the cognitive load of the reviewers. They are forced to go back and forth within the manuscript just to understand basic facts, which would have been much easier if they were presented in alignment with IMRaD structure.
The readers can also misinterpret the findings and might arrive at a wrong editorial decision. There have been many instances where a paper that should have been accepted was rejected just because the editors and reviewers misunderstood the manuscript.
Such confusions also cause delays and unnecessary revision cycles. Time is a crucial factor in research publishing. Being the first reporter of a scientific breakthrough or the pioneer of a certain technology has a huge leverage. Such a significant advantage should not be lost due to delays in the publication process.
By sticking to the universally accepted scientific writing guidelines, which advocate the use of IMRaD framework, you can avoid these costly mistakes and increase the chance of publication of your paper. In the next section let's discuss some academic writing tips to strengthen the IMRaD structure.
Step-by-Step Guide to Strengthening Each IMRaD Section
Introduction: In this section, you provide the context of your research and frame the problem that you are trying to solve. This section also serves to nudge the reader to the further sections by presenting a clear picture of what to expect in the manuscript.
Methods: Scientific research thrives on the transparency of communication and the repeatability of the experiments. The Methods section is used to explain the steps that you used, the tools and processes you employed in conducting your study and in arriving at your results. This section is very important because the editorial team needs to ensure that your methods are ethical and practically feasible so that other researchers can build on your results and further the scientific discourse.
Results: This is a key section where the outcomes of your research/experiment are lucidly explained. It is extremely important to present your results in a separate section with clean reporting, without leaving the readers to interpret at their will. Results make or break the research. Ultimately, what you discover is the most important part of your research. To present your findings clearly is, thus, the most important part of your manuscript.
Discussion: This section provides you the opportunity to share your insights on the results you achieved. You can elaborate the implications, limitations, and further possible iterations of your study in this section. Discussion section helps build conversations and open up new thoughts on the results you achieved.
Practical Tips for Structuring a Strong Manuscript
Using headings and subheadings
Proper headings and subheadings act as street signs directing a traveller within a large city. These little signboards help the reader navigate through the manuscript easily and also give them a hint on what to expect in a particular section of the manuscript. Use these signs liberally; yet, judicially. Too many headings and subheadings might also confuse the reader (and the writer too!). A rule of thumb is organize the relevant thoughts inside a heading and if there are more than one train of sub-thoughts, arrange them under the relevant, properly formatted subheadings.
Logical flow techniques
Logical flow of thought helps readers to maintain continuity of thought. When logical flow is missing, the continuity also goes for a toss and the readers are in for a bumpy ride. One simple technique is to structure your argument in a pyramid structure, where you present the key information first, then elaborate on the What, Why, How, What if, Why not arguments.
Avoiding redundancy
Redundancy means unnecessary repetition of arguments. Usually this happens when the writer is not following a structure like IMRaD. Without a structure, the writer might be repeating the key points in almost all the sections of the manuscript, just because they didn't define a proper slot for it. Redundant arguments hint the reviewers that the authors are not clear about what they want to convey, which may lead to a negative opinion.
Conclusion
Structure is, thus, an underrated but essential component of successful publishing of your research. You can ensure that your manuscript is structured according to universally accepted scientific writing guidelines by using the IMRaD framework to organize your manuscript. Such a structure helps in:
- Easy comprehension of your research by the reviewers and editors
- Timely acceptance and publication of your research
- Easy understanding of your paper by the readers
- Advancement of science by facilitating further research (which brings citations to your paper)
PaperPerfect helps you organize your research paper according to scientific writing guidelines and increases the odds for the acceptance of your manuscript for publication.