With the advent of digital publishing ecosystem, academic research publishing is no more a linear activity. After submission, a manuscript goes through a digital journey with too many touchpoints that involve third-party tools, AI-assisted authoring tools, editorial systems and reviewer networks. In such a scenario, ensuring manuscript security is a serious and important challenge. Each of these touchpoints pose significant risk. Protection of research data and unpublished manuscripts is gaining increasing importance as it directly involves research integrity, career of researchers, and safeguarding intellectual property.
This blog outlines potential risks for manuscript security and addresses how researchers can ensure their research data is handled safely in various manuscript submission platforms.
The Value of Research Data
A research manuscript is not just some text and diagrams arranged on a Word or PDF document. It is often the output of years of intellectual effort, funding investment, experimental data, novel methodologies, which are intellectual property of a person or a research group, and even sensitive discoveries or findings.
Various layers that attribute value to research data are as follows:
- Intellectual property that can lead to patents and commercial products with huge business prospects
- Competitive advantage in high-impact and rapidly evolving research areas
- Reputation for individuals, research institutions and funding bodies
When such sensitive information from research manuscripts submitted for peer-reviewed publication is breached, it leads to the loss of all three values mentioned above. Further, there is always a possibility of misuse or misinterpretation of the leaked data.
Common Risks that Researchers Overlook
Most of the security issues do not stem from malicious intent to breach data. However, they arise from routine practices that seem normal but are weak links in the manuscript handling process. Let's see some examples.
- Uploading confidential manuscripts to unverified random online platforms that lure researchers with lofty promises like 100% publication, low-cost open access, etc.
- Sending manuscript drafts and sensitive data over unprotected personal email accounts
- Using manuscript preparation platforms with unclear or no data ownership policies
Researchers often assume that manuscript submission platforms and other tools that they use before pre-submission are inherently safe. In reality, not all platforms are built with the necessary academic data security standards, nor do they comply with international data privacy and security regulations such as ISO/IEC 27001:2022.
Manuscript Security is Part of Research Integrity
Research integrity is not just ethical study design and transparent reporting. It also includes responsible handling of the research data throughout the publishing lifecycle. From this perspective, manuscript security is not just a technical concern. It is an important part of research integrity and is a key responsibility of the researcher to ensure that the manuscript is handled most securely.
Secure handling of manuscript ensures the following:
- Protection against data theft, plagiarism, and unauthorized use
- Preservation of the originality of the research and the findings
- Responsible and ethical treatment of sensitive data involving human subjects, clinical trial datasets, etc.
Negative Impacts of Data Breaches
The consequences of data breaches due to poor data security in publishing platforms can be very serious.
Potential impacts are as follows:
- Loss of first-reporter advantage
- Retractions due to integrity breach
- Breach of confidentiality agreement with sponsors
- Damage to personal and institutional reputation
- Loss of months/years of hard work
What Researchers Should Look for in Publication Tools
There are plenty of tools available today for manuscript preparation support, submission and peer-review. Researchers must evaluate the tools with a security-first approach before they even start uploading their manuscripts on those platforms. They must thoroughly check the security features mentioned in the platforms' websites.
Key features to look include the following:
- Data ownership policies that clearly indicate non-reuse of manuscripts
- End-to-End encryption of files in case they are stored and transmitted
- Role-based access controls for editors, reviewers and others in case of a manuscript submission platform
- Compliance with data security regulations such as ISO/IEC 27001:2022 and GDPR
Secure tools always treat your manuscripts with confidentiality as protected intellectual assets. They take utmost care to ensure the integrity, security and ethical handling of research data.
Building Trust Through Confidentiality and Compliance
If data security, integrity, ethics, and transparent reporting are the pillars of scientific research publishing, trust is the foundation of it. Data security in publishing plays a key role in building and maintaining that trust.
Publishers and platform builders must prioritize confidentiality, compliance, and robust security infrastructure that respect and uphold the researchers' work. On the other hand, researchers must take manuscript security seriously and ensure they do all the due diligence while handling their research data in various tasks in the publishing lifecycle. Such a responsible synergy between the publishing platforms and the researchers will ensure a healthier and more credible research publishing ecosystem where trust and integrity are nurtured and valued.